How to Research and Find the Right Grant Funders for Your Nonprofit
Most grant searches start the same way. There is a deadline in three weeks, a program that needs money, and a browser tab open to a search engine. You type in something like "grants for nonprofits," scroll through a few directories, land on a foundation whose website mentions your issue area, and start filling out the application. It feels productive. You are doing the work. But somewhere underneath it is the quiet worry that you are throwing darts in the dark and hoping one lands.
If that is your process, you are in good company, and it is not a character flaw. Nobody hands a development director a map of the funding world on their first day. What I have learned, though, is that the biggest lever on whether a grant gets funded is not how well the proposal is written. It is whether you found the right funder in the first place. Learning how to research and find the right grant funders for your nonprofit is the highest-return skill in the whole grant process, and most of us were never taught it.
Why Fit Beats Wordsmithing
Let me start with the numbers, because they reframe the whole task. Across all grant applications, the average success rate sits at around 15%. That means the ordinary outcome of any single submission is a no, and it has very little to do with how good your program is. When you feel discouraged after a rejection, the odds themselves are a big part of the story.
The spread underneath that average is where it gets interesting. A grant writer applying to funders who have never heard of the organization tends to see success rates around 30 to 40%, while applications to funders that already know the organization land closer to 80%. Sit with that gap for a second. The difference between a one-in-three shot and a four-in-five shot is not better prose. It is fit, familiarity, and relationship. The work of writing a proposal that gets funded matters, but it sits on top of a decision you make earlier: who you send it to.
There is a real cost to skipping that decision. Every application you write is hours you will not get back, and a small shop only has so many of them. When you spend those hours on a funder that was never going to say yes because your work sits outside their geography or their grant size, you have not just lost a grant. You have lost the time you could have spent on a funder who was actually a match. Finding the right funders is how you stop paying that tax.
What "The Right Funder" Actually Means
Before you can find the right funders, it helps to be honest about what "right" means, because it is more specific than "they fund nonprofits like ours." A genuine match usually comes down to four questions, and a no to any one of them is often a no to the whole application.
Do they fund your issue? Every funder has a focus area, and it is narrower than their website suggests. A foundation that funds "education" may only fund early childhood, or only within a single county. Read past the mission statement to the actual grants they make.
Do they fund your geography? A huge share of foundation giving is tied to place. Community foundations and family foundations often fund only within a specific city, county, or state, and they will not make an exception for a strong story from outside their lines.
Do they fund your size of request? If a funder's typical grant is $5,000 and you are asking for $75,000, you are not a fit, and the reverse is true too. Matching your ask to their normal range signals that you did your homework.
Do they fund the kind of support you need? Some funders only support specific programs; others will underwrite general operating costs. Encouragingly for nonprofits, that second door is opening wider. General operating support made up 40.3% of grants in 2024, up from 37.1% the year before. Knowing which kind of money a funder gives keeps you from asking for the one thing they never fund.
Turning these four questions into a checklist you run on every prospect — instead of eyeballing each funder from scratch — is exactly the kind of repeatable system that saves a development office hours every grant cycle.
Want to develop your fundraising skills? Take a look at my Claude Skills page.
Explore the Skills
Where to Actually Look
Here is the part that gets me genuinely excited, because the tools are better and cheaper than most fundraisers realize. The instinct is to start with a giant national database and work down. I would flip that. Start close, where your odds are best, and widen only as you need to.
Start with the funders already near you. Your warmest prospects are the funders who have given to you before, the ones who gave and then lapsed, and the funders your board members and staff have personal ties to. After that, look at organizations doing work like yours in your area and notice who funds them. Their supporters are, by definition, funders who give to your cause in your geography. I know why this step gets skipped. Reading the annual report of the organization across town feels like a detour, while typing your issue area into a national database feels like real work and returns a much longer list. But length is not the same as fit, and the shorter list is usually the one that gives.
Read the tax filings. Every private foundation files a public Form 990-PF, and it is the single most honest document about what a funder actually does. Buried in it is a list of every grant they paid last year, with the grantee names, cities and states, dollar amounts, and the foundation's application process and any geographic restrictions. A funder's website tells you what they say they care about. Their 990-PF shows you where the money went. When those two things disagree, believe the 990. You can pull these filings for free on ProPublica's Nonprofit Explorer or through Candid's tools.
Then widen with a database. The US has more than 150,000 private foundations, and you are not going to find the right ones by hand. Prospect research databases like Candid's Foundation Directory and Instrumentl let you filter that universe by issue, geography, and grant size in minutes. Many public libraries offer free access to Foundation Directory, so before you pay for a subscription, check whether your library card already gets you in.
Qualify Before You Apply
Research is only half the job. The other half is discipline about what you do with it, because a long list of maybes is almost as dangerous as no list at all. Once you have a set of possible funders, score each one against those four fit questions before you write a single word. If a prospect misses on issue, geography, or grant size, it does not go on your list, no matter how appealing the foundation sounds. A short list of genuine matches will always out-raise a long list of hopefuls.
The prospects that clear the bar are the ones worth real effort, and that effort usually means a relationship before an application. The 80% renewal figure exists because funders give to people they know, which is why building real relationships with foundation program officers often does more for your win rate than another draft of the narrative. A qualified prospect list also gives you something to plan around, so your applications stop being a scramble and start following a grants calendar and pipeline you can actually keep up with.
One more honest note. Even the best-researched grant list is one funding stream, and foundation priorities shift with the seasons. Private foundation grantmaking rose 4.2% in 2024, which is good news, but any single funder can change direction next year. The strongest shops treat grants as one engine among several and work to balance grants with other revenue so no one foundation holds the whole mission in its hands.
Behind much of the most durable funding is a generous business owner or family whose long-term giving, structured well, can steady a mission through the years when a grant cycle turns against you. Helping organizations and their donors build that kind of lasting plan is exactly what we do.
Interested in learning more about how a whole life insurance policy could benefit your nonprofit? Connect with a team member at Sage & Main.
Connect with Sage & Main
Where to Start
If your funder research right now is mostly a search engine and a deadline, you do not need to rebuild everything at once. A few focused changes will improve your matches more than any amount of extra applications.
1. List your warm prospects first. Before you open a database, write down every funder who has given to you, every one who lapsed, and every foundation your board and staff have a personal connection to. That list is where your best odds already live.
2. Read three 990-PFs this week. Pick three foundations you think might be a fit and pull their tax filings on ProPublica or Candid. Look at who they actually funded and for how much. You will learn more in twenty minutes than a week of reading mission statements.
3. Score before you write. For every prospect, answer the four fit questions — issue, geography, grant size, type of support. If any answer is no, take them off the list and give that time to a better match.
4. Check your library before you subscribe. Many public libraries offer free access to Foundation Directory. Confirm whether yours does before paying for a research tool you may already have.
A grant application is a small document carrying a big hope, and it is tempting to believe the whole outcome rests on the writing. It rarely does. When you start with the right funders, ones whose money already flows toward your issue, your place, and your size of ask, you are not gambling on being the best writer in the stack. You are asking people who were always likely to say yes. That is where grant success actually begins, and it is work any development office can start doing this week.
C.J. Bergmen is a pastor, licensed counselor, and fundraising strategist who helps organizations and generous individuals approach giving with honesty and long-term vision.