What Your Donors Would Tell You If You Asked: Running a Donor Survey
Every development office has an argument it has been having for years. Whether the printed newsletter is worth the postage. Whether four appeals a year is too many or not enough. Whether anyone reads the annual report or whether it travels from the mailbox to the recycling bin without being opened. The argument goes around the table, everyone has a position, and the decision lands with whoever has the most seniority. Nobody in the room has asked a donor.
The guessing is not harmless, and it turns out to be wrong in ways that are easy to measure. Bloomerang's 2026 Giving Signals Report, conducted with The Harris Poll among 1,003 active donors and 405 people with nonprofit fundraising decision-making responsibility, found that 69% of donors across all generations prefer email for fundraising communication, while nonprofit leaders reported leading their outreach with social media. That is a whole sector spending its Tuesday afternoons in one channel while its donors are waiting in another.
I spent years in ministry making calls exactly like that one, from instinct and from whatever the last conference speaker had said. What I have learned since is that the fastest way to settle most of these arguments is also the cheapest one available to you. You ask.
What It Costs to Keep Guessing
The sector-wide numbers make the case better than any argument I could build. The Fundraising Effectiveness Project reported that in the first quarter of 2026, dollars raised rose an estimated 4.3% while donor counts fell 0.8%, and retention actually declined within the Small, Midsize, Major, and Supersize donor segments. More money is coming from fewer people. That is a slow, quiet erosion, and it happens one donor at a time, usually without anyone announcing why they left.
This is not a failure of effort. The development directors I know are working harder than the people who write about them, and the retention problem is structural rather than personal. But structure is exactly what a survey helps you see. Penelope Burk built her entire donor-centered framework out of asking donors what they wanted and then reporting it back to fundraisers, and what came back was strikingly plain: donors said they needed prompt and meaningful acknowledgement, a gift assigned to something narrower than the mission as a whole, and a report on what the last gift accomplished before being asked for another. Three things. None of them expensive. Most development offices do one of the three reliably.
Her comparison of traditional and donor-centered practice is worth reading honestly. On the traditional side she cites measured behavior, including a 35% new-donor renewal rate drawn from Target Analytics data. On the donor-centered side she reports what donors said they would do, with 67% saying they would definitely or probably renew the next time they were asked. Stated intent always runs ahead of behavior. Even discounted, the gap between what donors say they need and what they routinely receive is where most of your first-time donors quietly disappear.
What to Ask, and What to Leave Out
A donor survey goes wrong most often at the design stage, when something short enough to produce answers turns into a twenty-question inventory nobody opens. Keep it to five or seven questions. A donor should finish it in under five minutes, and every question should be one you are willing to act on.
Five questions carry most of the weight:
Why did you first give to us? Open text. Ask this one even if you ask nothing else, because the language donors use here becomes the language of your next appeal.
Do you feel you know what your gift accomplished? Yes, somewhat, or no. A wall of "somewhat" is a communications problem you can fix in one quarter.
How would you prefer to hear from us, and how often? Channel and frequency in one question.
What would you like more of, and less of? Two boxes, side by side.
Is there anything you have wanted to tell us and never had a place to say? Leave it open. This is where the planned gift, the complaint, and the introduction to their business partner all show up.
Leave out anything already sitting in your database. You do not need to ask people how much they gave last year. Leave out satisfaction scales you have no plan to track over time, since a 7 out of 10 with no comparison point tells you nothing. And leave out any question whose honest answer you would ignore, because asking and then doing nothing is worse than never asking.
There is also a version of this that predicts behavior rather than describing it. DonorVoice, working from a nationally representative donor sample alongside files from nearly two dozen nonprofits in its donor retention lab, reported that a high-commitment donor gives on average 131% more than a low-commitment donor, and that prospective high-commitment donors can be identified through a three-question survey that outperformed the modeling tools then in common use. That research is more than a decade old, but the mechanism has held up: a handful of attitude questions tells you more about who will give again than gift history does on its own. It is a sharper way to segment your file than recency and amount alone.
Writing survey questions that produce usable answers is a skill, and it gets much faster once you have a repeatable process for drafting and testing them.
Want to develop your fundraising skills? Take a look at my Claude Skills page.
Explore the Skills
How to Run One Without a Budget
You do not need a research firm, and you do not need everyone to answer. A few hundred responses from a file of several thousand will settle most of the arguments your team is having.
Send it the way each group already hears from you. Donors who only ever receive mail should get a printed card with a stamped return envelope, because emailing a survey link to someone who never gave you an email address mostly measures who has email. Given that 69% preference for email, most of your file will be reachable online, but the exceptions tend to be your oldest and most loyal supporters, which is precisely who you least want to leave out.
Time it away from your asks. A survey landing three days after a year-end appeal reads as a follow-up ask, and a survey in mid-December competes with everything else in the mailbox. Late winter and early summer are quiet enough that a survey feels like what it is. Send different versions to different groups if you can manage it, since a monthly donor, a first-time donor, and someone you are trying to bring back after a lapse are not answering the same question about your organization.
For your top forty or fifty donors, skip the form entirely. Call them. Fifteen honest phone calls with major donors will teach you more than four hundred survey responses, and the call itself is a cultivation move that belongs in your moves management plan. Ask the same five questions, take notes in the database while you are still on the phone, and resist the urge to explain or defend anything you hear.
Open-ended questions are also where a legacy intention surfaces, since donors will often mention a will or an estate plan in a survey long before they would raise it in a meeting.
Interested in learning more about how a whole life insurance policy could benefit your nonprofit? Connect with a team member at Sage & Main.
Connect with Sage & Main
The Part Almost Everyone Skips
Running the survey is the easy half. The half that changes anything is closing the loop, and it is the step that gets dropped when the results land in the middle of a campaign.
Tell your donors what you heard and what you are changing because of it. A short note that says you asked, here is what came back, and here is the one thing we are doing differently will outperform most of what your development office mails all year. It proves you were listening, which is the whole reason the question mattered to them. That message belongs inside the same donor communications plan that governs your appeals and your acknowledgments, not off to the side as a one-time project.
Then let the answers actually move things. If donors tell you they do not know what their gift accomplished, that is a direct instruction about your impact report and about the specificity of your thank-you letter. If they tell you they like the personal stories and skip the organizational news, you have just been handed the editorial policy for your donor newsletter. Bloomerang's donor sample found that 94% are motivated when a nonprofit tells them exactly where their money goes and 90% by a clear explanation of the intended outcome, and your own survey will tell you how close your materials come to that standard.
One caution. A survey gives you a chorus, and the loudest voice in it is not the same as the most common one. One articulate donor who hates your new logo is not a mandate. Look for the patterns that repeat across dozens of responses, and hold the outliers as interesting rather than urgent.
Where to Start This Week
None of this requires a new line item, and you can have real answers in hand before the end of the month.
Write the five questions. Use the ones above or your own, but stop at five. Read them aloud to someone who does not work at your organization and cut anything they have to read twice.
Pick one segment and send it. Do not survey the whole file on the first try. Send to donors who gave in the last twelve months, learn how the process works, then widen it next time.
Book five phone calls. Choose five loyal donors, ask the same five questions, and write down their exact words rather than your summary of them.
Schedule the follow-up before you send. Put a date on the calendar for the message that reports back what you heard. If it is not scheduled in advance, it will not happen.
Those four steps replace a year of guessing with something you can build on, and they pair naturally with the calls and notes in a 90-day stewardship plan. What surprises most people is how willing donors are to answer. They gave you money because they care about something, and being asked what they think is a small confirmation that the relationship runs in both directions. That is also how a lot of quiet conversations begin, including the ones about a gift that outlives the donor.
Ask five questions. Read the answers. Change one thing, and tell them you did.
C.J. Bergmen is a pastor, licensed counselor, and fundraising strategist who helps organizations and generous individuals approach giving with honesty and long-term vision.