How to Diversify Your Ministry's Income Beyond Tithes and Offerings

A sunlit church fellowship hall with a long wooden table set with coffee mugs, ready for neighbors to gather.

Most church and ministry budgets rest on a single stream. The offering plate, the online giving button, and the faithful members who give week after week carry nearly everything, and for a long time that has worked well enough that nobody saw a reason to build anything else. Then a few key families move away, a season of lower attendance arrives, or a building repair shows up that no one planned for, and the whole budget starts to lean on the one thing it was never meant to carry alone. If you are trying to diversify your ministry's income without changing what makes your community a community, this post is for you.

This is not a failure of faithfulness. Tithes and offerings are the heart of how congregations fund their work, and I have no interest in moving anyone away from that. I spent years in pastoral ministry raising money myself, and our budget lived and died by what came in on Sunday. What I have learned since is that a ministry can add a few steady streams around that center, and that doing so protects the people who give faithfully by making their gifts less of a single point of failure.

What the Numbers Show

The clearest look at where congregations get their money comes from Faith Communities Today. In its 2020 study of congregational finances, authors Sean Payne, David King, and Susan Barnett found that the average congregation received about 85 percent of its income from individual giving such as tithes and offerings. Fundraising events and building rentals each supplied roughly 4 percent. Endowments, investments, school tuition, and capital campaigns each contributed about 1 percent. Evangelical Protestant congregations leaned on participant giving even more heavily, at 87 percent.

The same report put median congregational income at $120,000, a 20 percent decline from 2010, alongside a 38 percent drop in median weekly attendance over the same period. Those are 2020 figures, and every congregation's picture is different, but they describe a common pattern: a large share of income depends on a shrinking number of people showing up. When 85 cents of every dollar come from one source, even a modest change in that source reaches the whole budget.

There is a broader backdrop worth knowing as well. MinistryWatch's coverage of the Giving USA report noted that religion remained the largest destination for charitable gifts at $151.58 billion, or 23 percent of the total in 2025, while growing more slowly than other sectors. Generosity toward faith communities is still strong. The share of the whole is changing, which is another reason to widen the base.

Why One Stream Feels Safe

A single stream is simple. It needs no new skills, no outside relationships, and no conversations that feel awkward in a sanctuary. Many pastors and ministry leaders also carry a quiet worry that asking for anything beyond the offering will confuse the message about giving, or that seeking income elsewhere signals a lack of trust. I understand that worry, because I carried it too.

The tension softens when you see diversification as stewardship. A household that keeps all its savings in one account carries more exposure than it needs to. A ministry that builds a few additional sources is looking after the people it serves, and after the staff whose paychecks depend on a steady base. Nothing about that requires a departure from your theology of giving. It asks for a little planning, done with the same care you would bring to any other part of the work.

Five Places to Build a Second and Third Stream

None of these will replace the offering, and none of them need to. Each one can grow to carry a share of the load over time. Pick one or two that fit your community rather than trying all five at once.

1. Recurring and digital giving. This is the closest relative of what you already do, and the easiest place to begin. A 2025 Ministry Brands report on church giving, drawn from its own customers and surveyed churches, found that recurring gifts made up 42 percent of digital donations, that churches offering recurring giving were twice as likely to see overall giving rise, and that nearly half of the churches surveyed had not yet encouraged it. Because this is a vendor's data, treat the exact figures as a guide and not a promise. The direction is still helpful: a gift set up once and given every month turns an uneven offering into a steadier base. The mechanics are covered in this guide to starting a monthly giving program.

2. Designated gifts for specific ministries and projects. People often give more freely to something they can picture. A youth camp scholarship fund, a food pantry, a mission trip, or a roof repair gives members a concrete reason to give above their regular tithe. Name the need, say what a gift will do, and report back when it is done. The reporting matters as much as the ask, because it builds the trust that makes the next designated gift easy.

3. Facility use. Many congregations own space that sits empty through the week. Renting a fellowship hall to a community group, a preschool, or a recovery meeting can bring steady income and put your building at the center of neighborhood life. Rental income can raise tax questions, including how the IRS treats certain income from regularly carried-on activities that are unrelated to your exempt purpose, so ask your accountant or a church law adviser before you sign anything. I am not a lawyer, and the right answer depends on your structure and state.

4. Grants and community partnerships for the work you do outside the sanctuary. Foundations and local businesses generally do not fund worship, but many fund the food, tutoring, counseling, and care that congregations provide in their neighborhoods. Eligibility rules differ widely, and some funders require a separate nonprofit entity or fiscal sponsor, so read the guidelines closely before you invest time in an application. If you are curious how this works for a nonprofit with a small team, this look at fundraising for small nonprofits walks through where limited hours earn the most.

5. Legacy and planned gifts. This is the stream that changes the long-term picture the most, and it begins with a conversation, not a campaign. Members who have given for decades often want their generosity to outlive them and have never been asked how. A simple bequest line in a will, a beneficiary designation, or a gift from an IRA after a lifetime of giving can strengthen a ministry for generations. You can find a gentle approach in this post on talking about planned giving without scaring your donors, and a congregation-specific walk-through in this guide to starting a legacy giving conversation in your congregation.


Tracking recurring donors, designated funds, and the follow-up each one needs can feel like a second job. A repeatable workflow for appeals, donor updates, and thank-yous gives some of those hours back.

Want to develop your fundraising skills? Take a look at my Claude Skills page.
Explore the Skills


Keep the Heart of It Intact

Diversifying income works best when it grows out of the relationships your ministry already has. People who give regularly are paying attention to how their gifts are used and how they are thanked. If you add new streams while the basics slip, you will spend effort and gain little. A warm thank-you, an honest report on what the gifts accomplished, and a real understanding of why your members give are the foundation under every stream on this list. Those habits are the heart of teaching stewardship beyond tithing, and they make a new giving option feel like an invitation.

It also helps to be honest about timing. Recurring giving can start in a month. Designated gifts can start with your next need. Facility income and grants take longer, and legacy gifts often take years before they arrive and then arrive all at once. A ministry that begins small, with one new stream each year, is usually better off than one that launches five in a burst and lets three of them fade. The same patience applies when a larger need appears, since a church capital campaign succeeds more easily in a congregation that is already used to giving in more than one way.


Legacy gifts are where a ministry's long-term strength is often built, and some of the most useful tools for them sit outside the usual church budget. Many congregations never explore how a whole life insurance policy can fit into a donor's plans.

Interested in learning more about how a whole life insurance policy could benefit your nonprofit? Connect with a team member at Sage & Main.
Connect with Sage & Main


Where to Start This Week

If this resonates, here is what I would tell you to do this week.

  1. Pull last year's income report and sort it into categories: offerings, designated gifts, rentals, grants, and everything else. Write down the percentage that comes from your largest source. That single number tells you how exposed the budget is.

  2. Turn on a recurring gift option on your giving page, if you have not already, and invite your ten most faithful givers to consider it with a short personal note.

  3. Choose one specific need coming up in the next six months, such as a youth trip, a repair, or a benevolence fund, and write three sentences describing what a gift would accomplish.

  4. Make a list of the five longest-standing members of your congregation and pick one to have coffee with. Ask what they hope your ministry looks like in twenty years, and listen.

Your congregation has been generous for a long time, and that generosity is the best thing you have going. A few steady streams around it will give your leadership room to plan, to serve, and to say yes to opportunities when they come. I find that exciting, because it means the offering plate can keep doing what it does best while the rest of the budget stands on firmer ground.


C.J. Bergmen is a pastor, licensed counselor, and fundraising strategist who helps organizations and generous individuals approach giving with honesty and long-term vision.

Next
Next

Fundraising for Small Nonprofits: A Development Director's Guide